"Takes Medicare" vs. "Accepts Assignment": The Question to Ask Before the Visit
Reviewed by BillFighter · Facts and citations checked on this date
The front desk says "yes, we take Medicare," and that sounds like the end of the question. It is not. "Takes Medicare" covers three very different arrangements, and only one of them means the doctor has agreed to Medicare's price as full payment. The question that sorts them out is five words long: "Do you accept Medicare assignment?"
Assignment means the provider accepts the Medicare-approved amount — the price Medicare allows for a service — as payment in full. Medicare.gov puts it plainly: you get the lowest cost when your provider accepts that amount as payment in full for a covered service.
Exhibit A: The three answers hiding inside "we take Medicare"
- Participating. The provider signed an agreement to accept assignment on every Medicare claim. This is the answer you want.
- Non-participating. The provider is enrolled in Medicare but has not agreed to accept assignment across the board. They can decide claim by claim, and they can add an extra charge on top of Medicare's approved amount — a capped amount, and the cap is printed on your Medicare Summary Notice.
- Opted out. The provider left Medicare entirely and sees Medicare patients only under a private written contract. Medicare pays nothing, and no cap applies.
All three can truthfully say "we take Medicare." Only the first one has promised to take Medicare's price.
Exhibit B: When the answer is yes
A provider who accepts assignment can charge you only your deductible (what you pay each year before Medicare pays) and your coinsurance (your share of the approved amount). Medicare.gov adds two details worth knowing: the provider submits the claim to Medicare and can't charge you for submitting it, and they usually wait for Medicare to pay its share before asking you for yours. So a demand for the full charge up front, from a provider who accepts assignment, is itself worth questioning.
Exhibit C: When the answer is "we're non-participating"
A non-participating provider can ask you to pay the full amount at the time of service, and that part is allowed. They should still send the claim to Medicare for covered services; if they refuse, you can file it yourself.
The extra amount they can add on top of Medicare's approved amount is limited by federal regulation (42 C.F.R. § 414.48, the "limiting charge"). You do not need to compute it: your Medicare Summary Notice prints the result in the column called "Maximum You May Be Billed," with the cap already baked in. When the bill arrives, lay it next to the notice — a bill above that number is worth questioning in writing before you pay it. In some states, state law restricts the extra charge further or bars it for some patients; your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) can tell you what applies where you live.
We walked through the notice column by column in how to read a Medicare Summary Notice.
Exhibit D: When the doctor has opted out
An opt-out provider can only treat you under a private contract, and federal rules say what that paper must contain. It must be in writing and given to you before care, and it must state — in the regulation's words — that "Medicare limits do not apply to what the physician or practitioner may charge," and that "Medicare payment will not be made for any items or services furnished by the physician or practitioner" even if Medicare would otherwise have covered them (42 C.F.R. § 405.415). The rule also says the contract can't be signed while you need emergency or urgent care.
Read that as the warning it is: no approved amount, no cap, no Medicare payment, and Medigap won't pay either. The same regulation requires the contract to say you have the right to get the same covered services from a provider who has not opted out. Before signing one, call your SHIP — the counseling is free.
Your Move
- Before the visit, ask: "Do you accept Medicare assignment for this service?" Not "do you take Medicare."
- Check the answer on Medicare's Care Compare tool, which shows whether a provider accepts assignment.
- If they're non-participating, expect to pay up front, then match the bill to the "Maximum You May Be Billed" column on your Medicare Summary Notice. A bill above it is worth questioning.
- If they've opted out, get the private contract in writing before care, and remember you can take the same covered service to a provider who hasn't opted out.
Upload your bill and BillFighter shows which letter fits your situation, and what to do next. Check my bill, free → — the analysis is free. Personalized letters need the Fight Kit or In Your Corner.
Citations are to 42 C.F.R. § 405.415 and § 414.48, and to Medicare.gov's page on whether your provider accepts Medicare as full payment (2026). State rules on excess charges vary; check yours. BillFighter helps you understand and fight medical bills. We're a tool, not a law firm, and this isn't legal advice.